Appendix
      
      
        As an aid to an understanding of the circumstances which led to the
      
      
        giving of certain testimonies, the following notes have been prepared
      
      
        by the Trustees of the Ellen G. White Publications
      
      
        .
      
      
        Page 116, “Time to Begin the Sabbath”—For a period of about ten
      
      
        years Sabbathkeeping Adventists observed the Sabbath from 6 P. M.
      
      
        Friday to 6 P. M. Saturday. Elder Joseph Bates in his first pamphlet on
      
      
        the perpetuity of the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, published
      
      
        in 1846, had given reasons for the supposed scriptural support for the
      
      
        observance of the Sabbath in this way. He cited the parable of the
      
      
        laborers in the vineyard, the last group of which had been called at
      
      
        “the eleventh hour” of the day and had wrought but one hour. The
      
      
        reckoning was made with them “when even was Come.”
      
      
         Matthew 20:6,
      
      
        8, 12
      
      
        . Comparing this with Christ’s question, “are there not twelve
      
      
        hours in the day?” He argued that the “even” began with the twelfth
      
      
        hour, or six o’clock, reckoning with equatorial time or the beginning
      
      
        of the sacred year. Respect for his years and experience and his godly
      
      
        life may have been the main reasons for accepting his conclusions
      
      
        without further investigation.
      
      
        As time passed and the message spread, an increasing number
      
      
        of Sabbathkeepers questioned the practice and advocated the sunset
      
      
        time for reckoning the beginning of the Sabbath. A thorough Bible
      
      
        investigation of the question was made by Elder J. N. Andrews,
      
      
        who wrote a paper setting forth the Biblical reasons in favor of the
      
      
        sunset time. This paper was introduced and discussed on Sabbath,
      
      
        November 17, 1855, at the Conference in Battle Creek, Michigan,
      
      
        with the result that nearly, but not quite, all present were convinced
      
      
        that Elder Andrew’s conclusion was correct. The presentation of the
      
      
        subject to Mrs. White in this vision, given two days later, answered
      
      
        the questions lingering in some minds and effected unity among the
      
      
        believers. Commenting on this experience, as illustrating the office of
      
      
        the visions to confirm conclusions based on Biblical study rather than
      
      
        to introduce new teachings, Elder James White wrote later:
      
      
        652